Forensic Examination Techniques for Document Alterations

Significance of Alteration Detection

A primary function of FDE is the detection and identification of alterations made to a document after its original creation.1 Alterations, which encompass additions, erasures, obliterations, and page substitutions, can fundamentally change the meaning, intent, or value of a document, often with fraudulent intent.6 For instance, the amount on a check might be raised, a beneficiary added to a will, or a critical date changed on a contract.21 Uncovering these modifications is essential for verifying the integrity and authenticity of the document, exposing potential fraud, and ensuring that the document accurately reflects the original transaction or intent.4 The ability to scientifically detect and characterize alterations provides invaluable evidence in legal proceedings.

Adherence to Standards

The reliability and validity of forensic document examination hinge on the consistent application of scientifically sound methodologies and adherence to established standards and guidelines. Organizations such as the Scientific Working Group for Forensic Document Examination (SWGDOC) and the Academy Standards Board (ASB), through the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), develop and publish standards that outline best practices, terminology, training requirements, and specific examination procedures.1 Adherence to these standards ensures that examinations are conducted rigorously, results are reliable, and findings are presented clearly and objectively within the legal system.

Section 1: Understanding Document Alterations

Definition of Alteration

In the context of forensic document examination, an alteration is defined as any revision or modification made to a document after its initial preparation, effected through physical, chemical, electronic, or mechanical means, or any combination thereof.23 The fundamental purpose of an alteration is typically to change the original effect or meaning of the document.27 It is important to recognize that not all alterations are undertaken with fraudulent intent; corrections or modifications may be made legitimately with the knowledge and consent of all relevant parties.27 However, forensic examinations are most often concerned with fraudulent alterations, which are changes made covertly with the intent to deceive or cheat another party.27 These alterations are often performed in a manner intended to avoid detection under casual observation.27

Common Types of Alterations

Forensic document examiners categorize alterations based on the nature of the modification. This categorization provides a useful framework because different types of alterations leave distinct forms of evidence and require specific examination approaches. The primary types include:

• Additions/Insertions: This involves the introduction of supplementary material into the document.21 This can range from adding digits to raise the amount on a check, inserting words or phrases into existing text, writing between the lines (interlineations), or inserting entire pages into a multi-page document.21 Additions are often made in blank spaces or margins, and the appearance might be cramped if space is limited or unnaturally spread out if attempting to fill a larger gap.31 Examples include adding beneficiaries or conditions to wills or altering dates.21

• Erasures: This category involves the removal of original writing, typewriting, or printing from the document substrate.48 There are two main sub-types:

• Mechanical/Physical Erasure (Abrasion): This involves physically removing the media from the paper surface using abrasive tools such as rubber erasers, knives, sandpaper, or other sharp instruments.21 The defining characteristic of mechanical erasure is the physical disturbance or damage inflicted upon the paper fibers in the affected area.21

• Chemical Erasure: This method employs chemical agents, such as solvents or bleaching solutions (e.g., sodium hypochlorite, potassium permanganate, oxalic acid), to decolorize or dissolve the ink, effectively rendering it invisible.21 While the color is removed, the ink constituents may remain embedded within the paper fibers, and the chemicals often leave detectable traces or alter the paper's properties.50

• Obliterations: An obliteration involves covering or masking original entries to make them unreadable.8 Unlike erasure, the original writing is not removed but merely hidden. Common methods include heavily overwriting the original text with ink, scribbling over entries, or applying an opaque material such as correction fluid or tape.21

• Page Substitutions: This type of alteration applies specifically to multi-page documents. It involves removing one or more original pages and replacing them with different pages, potentially containing altered information.7 Executing a page substitution often requires disassembling the document (e.g., removing staples or other bindings) and then reassembling it, which can leave physical evidence.23

The distinction between mechanical and chemical erasure is particularly important from an examination standpoint. Mechanical erasure primarily leaves evidence of physical disruption to the paper surface, whereas chemical erasure leaves evidence of chemical interaction with the ink and paper, often detectable through altered optical properties like fluorescence. This fundamental difference dictates the most effective techniques for detection.

Relevant Standards

The examination of documents for alterations is guided by established standards. A key document in the United States is ANSI/ASB Standard 035, "Standard for the Examination of Documents for Alterations," developed by the Forensic Document Examination Subcommittee of the Organization of Scientific Area Committees (OSAC) and published by the AAFS Standards Board.2 This standard outlines minimum required procedures and commonly accepted techniques for these examinations.26

Section 2: Foundational Non-Destructive Examinations: Visual and Microscopic Techniques

Principle of Non-Destructive Analysis

A core principle in forensic science, and particularly in FDE, is the preservation of evidence. Therefore, examiners prioritize the use of non-destructive examination techniques whenever possible.7 These methods allow for the analysis of a document without physically or chemically altering it, ensuring its integrity for potential subsequent examinations or presentation in court. The initial assessment of a questioned document typically involves careful handling to prevent contamination or the introduction of new artifacts, followed by macroscopic and microscopic visual examinations.1 These foundational techniques leverage the basic principles of light interaction—reflection, transmission, and the casting of shadows—with the physical structure of the document to reveal potential anomalies indicative of alteration. They often serve as the first step in an examination, providing crucial observations that guide the application of more specialized techniques like UV/IR analysis or the use of a Video Spectral Comparator (VSC).

Magnification

The use of magnification is fundamental to FDE, allowing examiners to observe minute details that are invisible or indistinct to the naked eye.4 Examiners utilize a range of tools, from simple handheld magnifiers (providing low power magnification, e.g., 2x to 10x) to sophisticated stereomicroscopes (offering higher magnification, e.g., 10x to 50x or even up to 160x, and providing a three-dimensional view).4

Magnification enables the detailed inspection of:

• Ink line characteristics: Stroke direction, pen pressure variations, feathering, or bleeding.

• Paper fibers: Revealing disturbances, roughness, or lifting caused by mechanical erasure.21

• Printing processes: Identifying toner particles, ink spatter (from inkjet), or impression characteristics of typewriting.4

• Security features: Verifying microprinting or other intricate details on security documents.4

• Erasure sites: Detecting residual ink or graphite, or traces of erasing materials.27

• Intersecting lines: Potentially determining the sequence of strokes.

Oblique (Side) Lighting

Oblique lighting, also referred to as side lighting or grazing light, involves illuminating the document surface from a light source positioned at a very low, acute angle, sometimes nearly parallel to the surface.7 This technique is exceptionally effective at revealing subtle variations in the document's surface topography by exaggerating shadows and highlights.62

Oblique lighting is primarily used to detect:

• Indentations: Latent or visible impressions left on a sheet of paper from writing executed on an overlying sheet are clearly visualized as shadowed depressions.23

• Mechanical Erasures: The physical disturbance of paper fibers, surface roughening, or slight depressions caused by abrasive erasure are significantly enhanced by the shadows cast under oblique light.21

• Embossing and Impressions: Raised areas from embossed seals or depressed marks from stamps or typewriting become more apparent.64

• Paper Surface Texture: Reveals the general texture and any unnatural smoothness or roughness that might indicate alteration.

Transmitted Lighting

Transmitted lighting involves directing a light source through the document from the back, with the examiner viewing the front surface.7 This technique relies on variations in the paper's opacity or density to reveal internal structure or alterations.

Transmitted light is useful for identifying:

• Erasures: Areas thinned by mechanical abrasion or affected by chemical treatments often appear more translucent (brighter) than the surrounding paper when light is shone through.62

• Watermarks and Security Threads: Embedded security features within the paper structure are designed to be viewed under transmitted light.4 Damage or inconsistencies in these features can indicate tampering.

• Page Substitutions: Comparing the paper density, formation, or presence/absence of watermarks across pages using transmitted light can help detect substituted pages.26

• Repairs or Pasted Sections: Areas where paper has been added, patched, or glued may show differences in light transmission or reveal the outline of the added piece.

• Ink Density: Heavily inked areas may appear darker.

Evidence Revealed by Visual/Microscopic Techniques

These foundational techniques are crucial for detecting various signs of alteration:

• Disturbed Paper Fibers: A key indicator of mechanical erasure (abrasion).21

• Indentations: Can link documents, reveal missing information, or indicate sequence.23

• Inconsistencies: Differences in ink appearance (color, sheen), handwriting characteristics (style, size, spacing, alignment), or printing features (font, alignment) point towards additions, insertions, or substitutions.4

• Paper Thinning/Discoloration/Fluorescence Changes: Suggestive of mechanical or chemical erasures, or page substitution.26

While powerful, the effectiveness of these basic visual and microscopic techniques can be limited. The visibility of alterations like erasures can depend significantly on the skill of the forger and the quality of the paper used; better quality paper may show fewer signs of disturbance.27 Furthermore, these methods may not be sufficient to differentiate between inks that appear visually identical or to decipher completely obliterated text. Therefore, observations made using these foundational techniques often necessitate further examination using more specialized instrumentation, such as UV and IR light sources or the Video Spectral Comparator.

Section 3: Illuminating Alterations: Specialized Lighting (UV and IR)

Beyond the visible spectrum, ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) light provide powerful, non-destructive means for examining documents and detecting alterations. These techniques exploit the principle that different materials, particularly inks and paper components, interact uniquely with wavelengths of electromagnetic radiation outside the range of human vision.26 The chemical composition of an ink or the additives and coatings in paper determine how it absorbs, reflects, transmits, or luminesces (fluoresces or phosphoresces) when exposed to specific UV (~10-380nm) or IR (~700-1400nm) wavelengths.66 Forensic document examiners utilize specialized light sources, filters, and imaging equipment (often integrated into a Video Spectral Comparator) to induce and visualize these invisible reactions, revealing differences that are imperceptible under normal white light.7 This capability is particularly valuable for differentiating visually similar inks, detecting chemical erasures, and deciphering obliterated text.

Ink Differentiation

A primary application of UV and IR examination is the differentiation of inks that appear identical in color to the naked eye.55 Even inks of the same color class (e.g., black ballpoint) often have distinct chemical formulations from different manufacturers or even different batches from the same manufacturer.66 These compositional differences lead to varying responses under UV and IR illumination:

• IR Reflection/Absorption: In the infrared spectrum, inks exhibit a range of behaviors. Some inks are largely transparent to IR, reflecting most of the radiation, while others absorb IR wavelengths to varying degrees, appearing darker.67 Carbon-based inks and iron-gall inks, for example, tend to absorb IR strongly, while many modern organic dye-based inks may be transparent.67 By illuminating a document with IR light and capturing the reflected or transmitted radiation with an IR-sensitive camera or viewer, examiners can compare the opacity or transparency of different ink lines. A notable difference in IR absorption between two visually similar ink entries strongly suggests they were made with different pens, potentially indicating an alteration or addition.8 A classic example is detecting an altered amount on a check where the added numeral absorbs or reflects IR differently from the original writing.8

• IR Luminescence (IRL): This phenomenon occurs when an ink absorbs light energy (typically in the visible or UV range) and re-emits it as longer-wavelength infrared radiation.26 Not all inks luminesce, and those that do may exhibit different intensities or luminesce only when excited by specific wavelengths. Comparing the IRL properties of different ink entries under controlled excitation and viewing conditions (using appropriate filters) provides another powerful method for differentiation.37 IRL can sometimes distinguish inks that appear identical under IR reflection examination.68

• UV Fluorescence: When illuminated with UV light, certain components in inks or papers may absorb the UV energy and re-emit it as visible light (fluorescence).37 Differences in the color or intensity of fluorescence between ink lines or between an ink line and the surrounding paper can indicate the use of different materials or the presence of alterations.37

Detecting Chemical Erasures

Chemical erasures attempt to remove ink by using solvents or bleaching agents.21 These chemicals often interact not only with the ink but also with the paper itself, affecting sizing agents, optical brighteners, or paper fibers.23 These chemical changes frequently alter the paper's fluorescence characteristics. When examined under UV light, the treated area may fluoresce differently (brighter, duller, or a different color) than the surrounding, unaltered paper.23 This makes UV examination a primary non-destructive technique for locating suspected chemical erasures, even if the ink appears completely removed to the naked eye. Residual chemical traces might also be visualized using specific UV or IR techniques.

Revealing Obliterated/Faded Text

Specialized lighting is highly effective for deciphering writing that has been obliterated (covered over) or has faded over time.7 Success depends on the obliterating material and the underlying ink having different optical properties in the non-visible spectrum.

• IR Examination: Infrared light often penetrates materials that are opaque in visible light. If an obliterating ink (like a heavy marker or even some correction fluids) is transparent or semi-transparent to IR, while the original underlying ink absorbs IR, the original writing can be visualized through the obliteration using an IR camera and appropriate filters.54 Conversely, if the obliteration absorbs IR strongly and the original ink reflects IR or exhibits IR luminescence, the original writing may appear as lighter strokes against a dark background.55

• Enhancement of Faded Ink: Inks that have faded due to age or environmental exposure may still retain some components that interact with specific wavelengths of light. Using appropriate light sources (often IR) and filters, the contrast between the faded ink and the paper can be significantly enhanced, rendering the writing legible again.7

The power of UV and IR examination lies in their ability to leverage the distinct chemical fingerprints of inks and paper components, revealing variations invisible to the human eye. These non-destructive methods are indispensable tools for identifying alterations involving different materials. However, their effectiveness is contingent on the specific materials involved. If an alteration is made using an ink with very similar UV/IR characteristics to the original, or if an obliteration uses material with identical IR properties to the underlying text, these techniques may fail to differentiate them or decipher the hidden writing.68 This underscores the importance of a multi-technique approach in document examination.

Section 4: Advanced Analysis: The Video Spectral Comparator (VSC)

The Video Spectral Comparator (VSC) represents a significant technological advancement in forensic document examination, integrating multiple optical analysis techniques into a single, powerful workstation.55 It is designed to provide a comprehensive, non-destructive examination of questioned documents, enhancing the examiner's ability to detect subtle details, differentiate materials, and visualize information beyond the limits of human perception.50 Models like the Foster + Freeman VSC series (e.g., VSC6000, VSC8000, VSC9000, VSC80, VSC900) are widely used in forensic laboratories, immigration authorities, and government agencies globally.37

Function and Principle

At its core, the VSC is a sophisticated digital imaging system coupled with a wide array of controlled illumination sources and optical filters.50 It allows the examiner to illuminate a document with light spanning the electromagnetic spectrum from ultraviolet (UV), through the visible (Vis), and into the infrared (IR) regions.37 Various lighting geometries are typically available, including incident (direct), oblique (side), transmitted, coaxial, and spot/flood illumination.63

The system uses high-resolution cameras sensitive to these different wavelengths to capture images of the document's response to the illumination.50 Crucially, a selection of optical filters (e.g., longpass, shortpass, bandpass, polarizing) can be placed in the light path or before the camera to isolate specific wavelengths or phenomena, such as fluorescence or luminescence.50 The images are displayed in real-time on a monitor, and integrated software allows for image capture, enhancement, comparison, and analysis.50 Some advanced VSC models also incorporate a microspectrophotometer, enabling quantitative measurement of the light spectrum reflected from or transmitted through a tiny spot on the document.73

Key Capabilities (Applications in Alteration Detection)

The VSC's integrated capabilities make it invaluable for detecting various forms of document alteration:

• Ink Differentiation/Analysis: This is a cornerstone application. By systematically varying the illumination wavelengths and filters, the VSC can reveal subtle differences in the UV fluorescence, visible color, IR absorption, IR reflection, and IR luminescence properties of visually similar inks.7 This allows examiners to determine if different pens were used to create different parts of a document, strongly indicating additions or modifications.61 The microspectrometer provides quantitative spectral data for more rigorous comparison and discrimination of inks.73

• Visualizing Hidden/Security Features: VSCs excel at detecting and authenticating security features embedded in documents like passports, ID cards, and currency.62 Features such as UV fluorescent fibers or patterns, IR fluorescent inks, optically variable devices (OVDs), watermarks, security threads, microprinting, anti-Stokes inks, and taggants can be visualized using the appropriate illumination and filter combinations.73 This is critical for identifying counterfeit documents.

• Deciphering Obliterations: The VSC is a primary tool for non-destructively revealing writing obscured by correction fluid, heavy ink overwriting, or scribbling.7 By exploiting differences in the IR properties (transparency, absorption, luminescence) between the covering material and the original ink, the underlying text can often be made visible.54 It can also enhance inks that have faded over time.7

• Detecting Erasures: The VSC facilitates the detection of both mechanical and chemical erasures. Its high magnification and oblique lighting capabilities help visualize the disturbed paper fibers characteristic of mechanical erasures.61 Its UV illumination capabilities are essential for detecting the altered fluorescence often associated with chemical erasures.50

• Detecting Additions/Substitutions: By differentiating inks, the VSC can identify added text.7 By comparing the fluorescence and other optical properties of paper across different pages under UV and other lighting, it can help detect page substitutions.58

• Imaging and Documentation: The VSC allows examiners to capture high-quality digital images and video recordings of their observations under various examination conditions.50 This documentation is crucial for case notes, reports, and potential courtroom presentations. Software often includes tools for image enhancement, measurement, and side-by-side comparison.50

In essence, the VSC consolidates a suite of non-destructive optical examination tools into an efficient, powerful system. It significantly extends the examiner's ability to perceive subtle material differences and visualize information hidden from the unaided eye, making it indispensable in modern document examination. However, like UV and IR techniques generally, the VSC's ability to differentiate materials or reveal hidden information relies on the existence of differences in how those materials interact with the electromagnetic spectrum. If an alteration is made with materials that are optically indistinguishable from the original across the examined wavelengths, even the VSC may not detect it non-destructively, potentially necessitating other approaches like chemical analysis.

Section 5: Uncovering Erasures: Mechanical and Chemical

Erasures represent a common form of document alteration where original content is removed to allow for substitution or simply to eliminate information.48 Forensic document examiners classify erasures into two main categories based on the method of removal: mechanical (or physical) and chemical. Each type leaves characteristic traces on the document, requiring specific detection strategies.27 The detection approach directly targets the byproduct of the erasure method: physical damage for mechanical erasure, and chemical changes or residues for chemical erasure.

Mechanical Erasures (Abrasion)

Mechanical erasure involves the physical removal of ink or toner from the paper surface through abrasive action.27 This is typically accomplished using tools like rubber erasers, sandpaper, knives, or other sharp instruments.29

• Mechanism: The abrasive action physically scrapes or lifts the ink/toner particles along with the uppermost fibers of the paper.27

• Detection: The primary evidence of mechanical erasure is the physical disturbance of the paper surface.21 Examiners employ several techniques to detect this:

• Visual/Microscopic Examination: Close examination, especially under magnification (stereomicroscope), can reveal roughened or abraded areas where paper fibers have been disturbed, lifted, or broken.21 Remnants of the original ink or graphite may be visible clinging to the disturbed fibers.27 Sometimes, microscopic traces of the erasing material itself (e.g., rubber particles) can be detected.27 The erased area might also appear smudged.29

• Oblique Lighting: This is a highly effective technique for visualizing the disturbed surface texture. The low-angle light casts shadows across the roughened fibers and any slight depression caused by the removal of paper material, making the erased area stand out.27

• Transmitted Light: If the abrasion has significantly thinned the paper, the erased area may appear more translucent (brighter) when viewed with transmitted light.62

• Video Spectral Comparator (VSC): The VSC can be utilized for its microscopic and oblique lighting capabilities to enhance the visualization of fiber disturbance.58

• Electrostatic Detection Apparatus (ESDA): While primarily for indentations, the ESDA process is sensitive to surface disturbances and might visualize the erased area or related indentations.49

Chemical Erasures (Solvents/Bleaching)

Chemical erasure involves the use of liquid chemicals to remove or decolorize ink.21 Common agents include oxidizing/bleaching solutions (like sodium hypochlorite, potassium permanganate) or solvents (like acetone, tetrahydrofuran) capable of dissolving specific ink components.50

• Mechanism: These chemicals react with the ink dyes or pigments, breaking them down or converting them into colorless compounds.50 Solvents may dissolve the ink components, allowing them to diffuse into the paper.50 The chemical agent often affects the paper substrate as well, potentially reacting with sizing, coatings, or optical brighteners.50 Importantly, even if the color is removed, the ink's binder or other components might remain invisibly within the paper fibers.50

• Detection: Detecting chemical erasures relies on identifying the chemical changes to the ink or paper:

• Visual/Microscopic Examination: May reveal subtle paper discoloration, staining, or a "feathered" or blurred appearance of adjacent ink lines caused by the spread of the chemical agent.

• Ultraviolet (UV) Light: This is the most crucial technique for detecting chemical erasures.23 Many chemical erasing agents react with paper components (especially optical brighteners) or leave residues that alter the paper's natural fluorescence under UV illumination. The treated area often exhibits a different fluorescence intensity (brighter or duller) or color compared to the surrounding paper, creating a visible patch under UV light even when no erasure is apparent in normal light.37

• Video Spectral Comparator (VSC): The VSC's UV illumination capabilities are used to detect these characteristic fluorescence changes.37 Additionally, examination under various visible and IR wavelengths might reveal subtle discoloration or residual ink traces not fully removed by the chemical treatment.

• Chemical Tests (Destructive): Although generally avoided, specific chemical spot tests could potentially be used to identify the presence of residual erasing chemicals, but this would damage the document.

While these techniques are effective, successful detection depends on the skill of the alteration and the thoroughness of the erasure. A very carefully executed mechanical erasure on high-quality paper might leave minimal fiber disturbance.27 Similarly, a highly effective chemical erasure that leaves no residue and causes no discernible change in paper fluorescence might be extremely difficult or impossible to detect using non-destructive methods alone. This highlights a potential limitation in forensic document examination.

Section 6: Deciphering Obliterations

Obliteration is a type of document alteration where original writing or printing is intentionally covered or masked to render it unreadable.8 Unlike erasure, the original information is not removed from the paper but is simply hidden beneath another material. Common methods include using correction fluid or tape, heavily overwriting with the same or a different ink, or intense scribbling.21 The goal of the forensic document examiner is to non-destructively penetrate the obliterating layer and decipher the original underlying text.54

Analysis and Decipherment Techniques

Several techniques, primarily optical, are employed to analyze obliterations:

• Visual/Microscopic Examination: Initial examination under magnification may reveal clues. Sometimes, portions of the original writing might extend slightly beyond the edges of the obliteration.55 Differences in surface texture, sheen, or color between the obliteration and the surrounding area can be observed.55 If overwritten, microscopic examination might reveal differences in ink characteristics or line crossings.

• Transmitted Light: If the obliterating material (e.g., a single layer of correction fluid) is significantly less opaque than the original ink, viewing the document with strong transmitted light might allow partial or full decipherment of the underlying text. However, this is often ineffective against heavy ink or multiple layers of correction fluid.54

• Infrared (IR) Examination (using VSC): This is the most powerful and commonly used non-destructive technique for deciphering obliterations.54 Its success relies on the principle that the obliterating material and the underlying ink may have different absorption, reflection, or luminescence properties in the infrared portion of the electromagnetic spectrum, even if they appear visually similar or opaque.54

• Differential IR Absorption/Reflection: Many common writing inks (especially those containing carbon black or iron) absorb IR radiation strongly, while many pigments used in correction fluids or some colored inks may reflect IR radiation (i.e., are transparent to IR).54 By illuminating the document with IR light and viewing it through an IR filter (typically within a VSC), the examiner can effectively "see through" an IR-transparent obliteration to visualize the IR-absorbing original text beneath it.54 Conversely, if the obliteration absorbs IR and the original ink reflects IR, the original writing might appear as light strokes against a dark background.

• Differential IR Luminescence (IRL): If the original ink and the obliterating ink exhibit different luminescence properties when excited by specific wavelengths (often visible light), this difference can be captured using IR filters and imaging, allowing the underlying text to be distinguished from the obliteration.55

• Physical Removal (Destructive): In cases where optical methods fail, particularly with thick applications of correction fluid, careful physical removal might be considered as a last resort.56 This involves meticulously scraping away the obliterating layer under magnification using a scalpel or similar tool. However, this method is destructive, risks damaging the underlying writing and the document itself, and requires prior authorization.56

The success of non-destructively deciphering obliterations is almost entirely dependent on finding a difference in the optical properties (especially IR response) between the original writing and the covering material. If an obliteration is performed using an ink that has identical IR absorption, reflection, and luminescence characteristics as the underlying ink, non-destructive decipherment using IR techniques will likely fail. Correction fluid, while visually opaque, is often penetrable using IR methods, making it a less secure means of obliteration compared to overwriting with a carefully chosen, IR-opaque ink.54

Section 7: Identifying Additions and Insertions

Additions and insertions involve adding new material (handwriting, typewriting, printing) to a document after its original preparation, often in blank spaces, between lines (interlineations), or at the end of existing text.21 The forensic challenge is to detect this added material and differentiate it from the original content. Detection relies on identifying inconsistencies between the added material and the surrounding original document in terms of the materials used (ink, paper), the method of production (handwriting style, printing characteristics), or the physical placement and alignment.4 The underlying principle is that it is exceedingly difficult for a person making a fraudulent addition to perfectly replicate all aspects of the original document's creation and context.

Ink Analysis

Comparing the ink of the suspected addition with the ink of the original, surrounding text is a primary method for detection.

• Video Spectral Comparator (VSC) Examination: Non-destructive analysis using the VSC is typically the first step.21 The examiner compares the UV fluorescence, visible color characteristics, IR absorption/reflection, and IR luminescence of the ink in the suspected addition to the ink in the undisputed original portions of the document.21 Significant differences in any of these optical properties indicate that different inks were used, providing strong evidence of an addition.21

• Chromatography (TLC/GC-MS): If VSC examination is inconclusive (i.e., the inks show similar optical properties) or if more detailed chemical information is required, destructive analysis via chromatography may be employed.55 Techniques like Thin-Layer Chromatography (TLC) or Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS) separate the ink into its constituent components (dyes, pigments, solvents, resins).7 The resulting chromatogram provides a chemical profile of the ink. If the chromatogram from the suspected addition differs significantly from that of the original ink (e.g., different number of components, different retention times/Rf values, presence/absence of specific compounds), it confirms that different inks were used.55 Due to its destructive nature, requiring the removal of small ink samples from the document, chromatography is used judiciously, typically only after non-destructive methods have been exhausted and with appropriate authorization.7

Handwriting Analysis

If the addition involves handwriting, examiners compare its characteristics to the surrounding original handwriting or to known handwriting samples (exemplars) of the purported author.21

• Inconsistencies: Examiners look for significant, unexplained differences in handwriting features such as:

• Size and Proportion: Added writing might be smaller or larger to fit available space.31

• Slant: The angle of writing might differ.31

• Spacing: Words or letters might appear unusually crowded or spread out.21

• Alignment: The positioning relative to a baseline might be inconsistent.21

• Letter Forms: The way specific characters are constructed might vary.97

• Line Quality and Pen Pressure: Fluency, speed, and pressure patterns might differ.21

• Overall Style: The general appearance and skill level may be inconsistent.

Typeface/Printing Analysis

For additions made using typewriters or computer printers, examiners compare the added text to the original printed/typed portions.4

• Mismatches: Indicators of added typewritten or printed material include:

• Font: Differences in typeface design, size, or style (e.g., bold, italics).4

• Alignment/Spacing: Inconsistent character or line spacing, margins, or vertical/horizontal alignment.4

• Ink/Toner: Differences in the appearance, color, or microscopic characteristics of the ink or toner.4

• Printing Process Defects: Unique marks or defects produced by a specific typewriter or printer might be present in the original text but absent in the addition, or vice versa.23

The detection of additions and insertions fundamentally relies on identifying deviations from the established characteristics of the original document. Whether through differences in ink chemistry, handwriting habits, or printing technology, inconsistencies serve as red flags indicating that material may have been introduced after the document's initial creation.

Section 8: Detecting Page Substitutions

Page substitution is an alteration specific to multi-page documents, where one or more original pages are removed and replaced with fraudulent pages.7 This might be done to change the terms of a contract, alter beneficiaries in a will, or insert falsified records. Detecting page substitution requires a meticulous, holistic examination of the entire document, comparing characteristics across all pages to identify any discontinuities or anomalies that break the expected uniformity.21 A genuine, unaltered multi-page document, created as a single entity, should exhibit consistency in its physical components (paper, ink), production method (printing), binding, and content flow.

Paper Examination

Comparing the physical and optical properties of the paper used for each page is a critical step.21

• Comparison: Examiners assess characteristics such as:

• Color and Brightness: Subtle differences in shade or brightness level.58

• Weight and Thickness: Variations detectable by feel or measurement.60

• Texture and Finish: Differences in surface smoothness or coating.60

• Opacity: How much light passes through (using transmitted light).60

• Fluorescence: Response under UV illumination (using VSC or UV lamp). Papers from different batches or manufacturers often have different levels or colors of fluorescence due to variations in optical brighteners.23 A case example demonstrated detecting a substituted page based on differing fluorescence.58

• Watermarks: Presence, absence, or position of watermarks should be consistent.60

• Indicators: Any significant variation in these properties between one page and the others is suspicious and suggests the anomalous page may be a substitution.23

Printing Method Analysis

Consistency in the printing method and characteristics across all pages is expected in an authentic document.7

• Comparison: Examiners evaluate:

• Printing Process: Was the same method (e.g., laser, inkjet, offset) used for all pages? Microscopic examination or VSC analysis can help identify the process.7

• Ink/Toner: Are the color, sheen, and microscopic appearance of the ink or toner consistent? VSC can differentiate inks/toners based on spectral properties.21

• Font and Formatting: Are the typeface, font size, character spacing, line spacing, margins, and overall layout consistent across all pages?.21

• Alignment: Is the text block positioned consistently on each page?.23

• Machine Defects: Does a unique defect from a specific printer or copier appear consistently (or inconsistently) across pages?

• Indicators: Unexplained differences in any of these printing characteristics on one or more pages compared to the rest strongly suggest substitution.23

Binding/Staple Hole Analysis

If the document is bound or stapled, the binding mechanism provides crucial evidence.21 This is often a powerful indicator because physically disassembling and reassembling a document frequently leaves tell-tale signs.

• Examination: Examiners meticulously inspect the staple(s), staple holes, or other binding holes (e.g., from three-hole punches) on every page.58

• Indicators:

• Multiple Hole Sets: The presence of extra staple holes that do not align with the current staple indicates the page was previously stapled differently, possibly as part of another document or in a different page order.23

• Misalignment: Holes on one page not aligning perfectly with holes on adjacent pages when the document is closed.23

• Hole Damage: Tears, elongation, or distortion around staple holes can indicate forceful removal of a staple.27

• Staple Condition: Signs of manual manipulation of the staple itself.27

• Inconsistent Hole Placement/Type: Differences in the location, size, or shape of binder holes (e.g., pre-punched vs. manually punched).58

• Impression Evidence: Impressions from the stapler mechanism itself might be compared.27

• A single, undisturbed set of perfectly aligned staple holes across all pages supports the document's integrity.91

Document Continuity

Beyond physical characteristics, the logical flow and consistency of the content itself are assessed.21

• Assessment: Examiners read through the document checking for:

• Page Numbering: Correct and consistent sequence.

• Formatting: Consistent margins, line spacing, paragraph indentation, headers/footers.

• Content Flow: Logical progression of ideas or information without abrupt breaks or non-sequiturs between pages.

• Language/Style: Consistency in terminology, grammar, and writing style.

• Cross-Page Consistency: Alignment of lines or elements that should continue across page breaks.

• Indicators: Unexplained inconsistencies in numbering, formatting, content flow, or style between pages can signal a potential substitution.23 Indented writing analysis using ESDA can also play a role; if impressions on one page correspond to writing on a non-adjacent page, it might indicate the original page order was different.58

Detecting page substitution requires careful, methodical comparison across multiple features. An anomaly in a single feature might have an innocent explanation, but inconsistencies across several features (e.g., different paper fluorescence, misaligned staple holes, and inconsistent printing) build a strong case for page substitution.

The forensic examination of questioned documents for alterations is a multifaceted discipline requiring specialized knowledge, meticulous techniques, and sophisticated instrumentation. Identifying additions, erasures, obliterations, and page substitutions is crucial for verifying the authenticity and integrity of documents contested in legal and administrative settings.

Forensic document examiners employ a systematic approach, typically beginning with non-destructive visual and microscopic techniques. Magnification, oblique lighting, and transmitted light reveal fundamental physical evidence such as disturbed paper fibers, indentations, and variations in paper thickness or opacity. Specialized lighting, particularly in the ultraviolet (UV) and infrared (IR) regions, allows examiners to exploit the differential optical properties of inks and papers based on their chemical composition. These techniques are highly effective for differentiating visually similar inks, detecting the subtle traces of chemical erasures, and deciphering obliterated text.

The Video Spectral Comparator (VSC) represents a cornerstone of modern document examination, integrating many of these optical techniques into a single workstation. It provides enhanced capabilities for ink analysis, visualization of hidden security features, and detection of various alterations through multi-spectral imaging and, in some models, microspectrophotometry. Specific methodologies target the unique evidence left by different alteration types: disturbed fibers and surface topography for mechanical erasures; fluorescence changes for chemical erasures; differential IR responses for obliterations; and inconsistencies in ink, handwriting, or printing for additions. Page substitution detection relies on a holistic assessment, identifying discontinuities in paper characteristics, printing methods, binding evidence (especially staple holes), and overall document flow. While non-destructive methods are preferred, destructive techniques like ink chromatography (TLC, GC-MS) offer powerful chemical analysis capabilities when necessary, albeit at the cost of altering the evidence.

Ultimately, a comprehensive examination often relies on the synergy of multiple techniques, as findings from one method can corroborate or guide the application of others. The interpretation of findings requires significant training and experience, as examiners must distinguish between natural variations and significant discrepancies indicative of alteration. While forensic science strives for objectivity, the evaluation of complex features can involve subjective judgment, underscoring the importance of adherence to standardized procedures, rigorous methodology, quality assurance measures like peer review, and clear reporting of findings and limitations.2 Despite the sophistication of these techniques, limitations exist, particularly when dealing with non-original documents or skillfully executed alterations using materials with similar properties.102 Nonetheless, forensic document examination provides critical tools for uncovering the truth hidden within questioned documents.

Table 1: Overview of Alteration Detection Techniques

Alteration Type

Key Indicators

Primary Detection Techniques

Destructive?

Addition/ Insertion

Different ink properties (color, UV/IR response), handwriting inconsistencies (style, spacing, alignment), typeface/printing mismatches, cramped/unnatural spacing

Visual/Microscopic, UV/IR Light, VSC, Chromatography (Ink Analysis), Handwriting Comparison, Printing Process Analysis

Ink Chromatography (Y), Others (N)

Mechanical Erasure

Disturbed/roughened paper fibers, paper thinning, ink/graphite remnants, eraser debris, surface depression

Visual/Microscopic, Oblique Light, Transmitted Light, VSC, ESDA

N

Chemical Erasure

Paper discoloration/staining, altered paper fluorescence (UV), blurred adjacent inks, ink residue

UV Light, VSC, Visual/Microscopic

N

Obliteration

Covering material (ink, correction fluid), overwriting, scribbling

IR Light/Luminescence (VSC), Visual/Microscopic, Transmitted Light (limited), Physical Removal (destructive)

Physical Removal (Y), Others (N)

Page Substitution

Inconsistent paper (type, weight, fluorescence), inconsistent printing (process, font, alignment), misaligned/extra staple holes, inconsistent page numbering/formatting/content flow

Paper Analysis (Visual, UV/IR), Printing Process Analysis (Microscopic, VSC), Staple/Binding Hole Analysis (Visual/Microscopic), Indentation Analysis (ESDA)

N

Works cited

1. FORENSIC DOCUMENT UNIT TEST METHODS - IN.gov, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.in.gov/isp/labs/files/Documents_Test_Methods_10-02-2023.pdf

2. Questioned document examination - Wikipedia, accessed April 20, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Questioned_document_examination

3. Questioned document examination (QDE) | EBSCO Research Starters, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/science/questioned-document-examination-qde

4. Forensic Document Examination: Techniques and Types - Academic Block, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.academicblock.com/science/web-of-forensic-science/forensic-document-examination

5. An Overview of Forensic Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.robsonforensic.com/articles/forensic-document-examination-expert-witness

6. Become a Forensic Document Examiner, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.forensicscolleges.com/careers/forensic-document-examiner

7. Forensic Document Examination: How It's Done, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.forensicsciencesimplified.org/docs/how.html

8. A Simplified Guide To Forensic Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.forensicsciencesimplified.org/docs/QuestionedDocuments.pdf

9. Sandra L. Homewood - JurisPro Expert Witness Directory, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.jurispro.com/files/documents/doc-937738922-resume.pdf

10. Analyzing documents effectively - Southeast Fraud Investigation Services, accessed April 20, 2025, http://www.sefraudinvestigationservices.com/2017/07/analyzing-documents-effectively/

11. Forensic Document Examiner San Bernardino & Los Angeles | Forensic QDE Lab, LLC, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.forensicqde.com/

12. The Use of Forensic Document Examiners in Florida Will Contests, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.floridabar.org/the-florida-bar-journal/the-use-of-forensic-document-examiners-in-florida-will-contests/

13. Decoding Handwriting: The Life of a Forensic Document Examiner - Litigation Legal Insight Group, accessed April 20, 2025, https://litiligroup.com/decoding-handwriting-the-life-of-a-forensic-document-examiner/

14. A Guide to Non-Destructive Methods for Examining Alterations in Handwritten Text - Regula, accessed April 20, 2025, https://regulaforensics.com/blog/examining-alterations-in-handwriting/

15. estateplanning.osbar.org, accessed April 20, 2025, https://estateplanning.osbar.org/files/2021/07/Est_2021Jul.pdf

16. Holographic Wills: What You Need to Know - Western Forensic Document Examiner, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.westernforensicdocumentexaminer.com/holographic-wills-what-you-need-to-know/

17. Questioned Documents Section | Iowa Department of Public Safety, accessed April 20, 2025, https://dps.iowa.gov/divisions-iowa-department-public-safety/iowa-division-criminal-investigation/iowa-dci-criminalistics-laboratory/questioned-documents-section

18. Document Examination | Idaho State Police, accessed April 20, 2025, https://isp.idaho.gov/forensics/document-examination/

19. Questioned Document Examination - ZEISS, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.zeiss.com/microscopy/en/applications/forensics/questioned-document-examination.html

20. Holographic Wills and the Essential Role of Forensic Document ..., accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.documentexaminer.info/blog/holographic-wills-and-the-essential-role-of-forensic-document-examiners-in-estate-disputes/

21. Forensic Services - Thomas Vastrick, accessed April 20, 2025, https://thomaswvastrick.com/forensic-services/

22. Forensic Document Examiners | Illinois State Bar Association, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.isba.org/experts/forensicdocumentexaminers

23. Detecting Alterations in Documents - Meredith DeKalb Miller ..., accessed April 20, 2025, https://dekalbmiller.com/detecting-alterations/

24. swgdoc, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.swgdoc.org/

25. How to Recognize a Forged Will: Signs to Look For, accessed April 20, 2025, https://hagestadlaw.com/blog/signs-of-a-forged-will

26. www.aafs.org, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.aafs.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/035_Std_e1.pdf

27. Alteration in documents.pptx - SlideShare, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/alteration-in-documentspptx/259910040

28. Introduction to Forensic Science and Criminology → QD Part 4 – The Examination of Questioned Document - wilber-learndev, accessed April 20, 2025, https://wilber-learndev.com/courses/introduction-to-forensic-science-and-criminology/lessons/qd-part-4

29. 10.Examination_of_Erasures.ppt - SlideShare, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.slideshare.net/PallaviKumari112/10examinationoferasuresppt

30. Detection of Alteration in Suspected Documents– A Case Study, accessed April 20, 2025, https://forensics.org.my/mjofs/pdf/fssmVol.8No.1/Article%2004.pdf

31. Module No.17: Alteration in Documents- Addition and overwriting, accessed April 20, 2025, https://lkouniv.ac.in/site/writereaddata/siteContent/202003241550008847kamyani_vajpayee_Alteration_in_Documents_addition.pdf

32. Forensic Document Examination in the 21st Century, accessed April 20, 2025, https://api.pageplace.de/preview/DT0400.9781000245363_A40609520/preview-9781000245363_A40609520.pdf

33. ANSI/ASB Standard 011, First Edition 2022 Scope of Expertise in Forensic Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.aafs.org/sites/default/files/media/documents/011_Std_e1.pdf

34. Laboratory Services Questioned Documents - Public now, accessed April 20, 2025, https://docs.publicnow.com/viewDoc.aspx?filename=97845\EXT\91E161E5F94F751DC772D5505578A2BD40E65A75_00E6C52D2A35C4CF94AE1DBAE396F6C46E8D4F28.PDF

35. SWGDOC Standard for Minimum Training Requirements for Forensic Document Examiners, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.swgdoc.org/documents/SWGDOC%20Standard%20for%20Minimum%20Training%20Requirements%20for%20Forensic%20Document%20Examiners.pdf

36. Published Standards - swgdoc, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.swgdoc.org/index.php/standards/published-standards

37. Forensic Document Examination Analytical Methods - Idaho State Police, accessed April 20, 2025, https://isp.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/Forensics/currentAMs//Document%20Examination/Forensic-Document-Examination-Analytical-Methods-Rev-2.pdf

38. Forensic Science Standards Library | NIST, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/osac/standards-library

39. Forensic Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/document/communicating-forensic-findings-forensic-document-examination

40. OSAC 2022-S-0034 Standard for the Expression of Source Opinions in Forensic Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/document/osac-2022-s-0034-standard-expression-source-opinions-forensic-document-examination-version

41. NIST Report Highlights Key Challenges in Forensic Science and Provides Strategies for Addressing Them - CSAFE, accessed April 20, 2025, https://forensicstats.org/blog/2024/10/15/nist-report-highlights-key-challenges-in-forensic-science-and-provides-strategies-for-addressing-them/

42. OSAC 2024-S-0017 Standard Guide for Forensic Physical Fit Examination of Documentary Evidence, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/document/osac-2024-s-0017-standard-guide-forensic-physical-fit-examination-documentary-evidence

43. NIST Publishes Review of Digital Forensic Methods, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/news-events/news/2022/05/nist-publishes-review-digital-forensic-methods

44. Forensic Science Standards Program | NIST, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.nist.gov/spo/forensic-science-standards-program

45. NIST SP 800-86, Guide to Integrating Forensic Techniques into Incident Response, accessed April 20, 2025, https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/legacy/sp/nistspecialpublication800-86.pdf

46. Forensic Handwriting Examination and Human Factors: Improving the Practice Through a Systems Approach - NIST Technical Series Publications, accessed April 20, 2025, https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ir/2020/NIST.IR.8282.pdf

47. 5.02 Other Clues on the Document - ACCESS Virtual Learning, accessed April 20, 2025, https://accessdl.state.al.us/AventaCourses/access_courses/forensic_sci_ua_v22/05_unit/05-02/05-02_learn_text.htm

48. Forensics- Ch. 9 Handwriting Analysis, Forgery, Counterfeit Flashcards | Quizlet, accessed April 20, 2025, https://quizlet.com/144598184/forensics-ch-9-handwriting-analysis-forgery-counterfeit-flash-cards/

49. forensics ch 17: Forensic Document Examination Flashcards - Quizlet, accessed April 20, 2025, https://quizlet.com/174381166/forensics-ch-17-forensic-document-examination-flash-cards/

50. subject forensic science, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.lkouniv.ac.in/site/writereaddata/siteContent/202003241550008847kamyani_vajpayee_Alteration_in_documents_erasures.pdf

51. lkouniv.ac.in, accessed April 20, 2025, https://lkouniv.ac.in/site/writereaddata/siteContent/202003241550008847kamyani_vajpayee_Alteration_in_documents_erasures.pdf

52. Questioned Documents Methods Manual - Ohio Attorney General, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.ohioattorneygeneral.gov/Files/Law-Enforcement/BCI/Laboratory-Division/BCI-Questioned-Documents-Methods-Manual-12302019.aspx

53. (PDF) Using an erasable ink to forge documents, medico-legal study on evaluating them in detection and prevention the forgery - ResearchGate, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282756020_Using_an_erasable_ink_to_forge_documents_medico-legal_study_on_evaluating_them_in_detection_and_prevention_the_forgery

54. Document Examination | Forensic Document Examiner | James A ..., accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.documentexaminer.info/document-examination-services/

55. Alteration/Obliteration & Ink Examinations - Questioned Documents, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.questioneddocuments.com/alteration-obliteration-ink-examinations/

56. Questioned Documents Unit Manual - City of San Diego, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.sandiego.gov/sites/default/files/july2019toseptember2019.pdf

57. Forensic Document Examination: Principles, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.forensicsciencesimplified.org/docs/principles.html

58. Questioned Documents Examination Test No. 24-5211 Summary Report, accessed April 20, 2025, https://cts-forensics.com/reports/24-5211_Web.pdf

59. Forensic Document Examination Analytical Methods - Idaho State Police, accessed April 20, 2025, https://isp.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/Forensics/currentAMs/Document%20Examination//Forensic-Document-Examination-Analytical-Methods-Rev-2.pdf

60. FORENSIC DOCUMENT EXAMINATION ANALYTICAL METHODS - Idaho State Police, accessed April 20, 2025, https://isp.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/Forensics/archivedAMs/since/Document%20Examination/Forensic%20Document%20Examination%20Analytical%20Methods%20Rev%201.pdf

61. Analysis of Selected Methods Used in Forensic Paper-Based Document Examination - IISTE.org, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.iiste.org/Journals/index.php/CMR/article/viewFile/44976/46416

62. A Comprehensive Guide to Instrumentation Techniques in Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://hawkeyeforensic.com/2024/01/25/a-comprehensive-guide-to-instrumentation-techniques-in-document-examination/

63. Lab - Document Examination, Handwriting Analysis, Forensic Document Services, accessed April 20, 2025, https://qdewill.com/oldsite/lab_tour.htm

64. Forensic Document Examination Training Manual - Idaho State Police, accessed April 20, 2025, https://isp.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/Forensics/currentAMs/Document%20Examination//Document-Examination-Training-Manual-Rev-4.pdf

65. Indented Writing Detection - Board Certified Forensic Document and Handwriting Expert, accessed April 20, 2025, https://qdewill.com/labtour.html

66. Questioned Documents - HORIBA, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.horiba.com/sgp/scientific/applications/others/pages/questioned-documents/

67. Ink Differentiation with Infrared Techniques - Journal of Pressure ..., accessed April 20, 2025, https://pressurevesseltech.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org/forensicsciences/article-pdf/7093873/10_1520_jfs10048j.pdf

68. Ink Differentiation with Infrared Techniques, accessed April 20, 2025, http://sheismylawyer.com/She_Thinks_In_Ink/Pens/How_To/JFS184730418.pdf

69. Ink Differentiation - Questioned Documents - Norwitch Document Laboratory, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.questioneddocuments.com/ink-differentiation/

70. INK DIFFERENTIATION WITH INFRARED TECHNIQUES - Office of Justice Programs, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/ink-differentiation-infrared-techniques

71. The Hidden Power Of Forensic Light Source In Forensic Science - Simplyforensic, accessed April 20, 2025, https://simplyforensic.com/forensic-light-sources-in-forensic-science/

72. Video Spectral Comparator(VSC 6000/HS) For Questioned Documents Examination | PPT, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/video-spectral-comparatorvsc-6000hs-for-questioned-documents-examination/265195812

73. VSC the premiere range of QDE workstations | Foster + Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/vsc-premiere-range-qde/

74. Video Spectral Comparator | PPT - SlideShare, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/vsc-palash-mehar/240127870

75. VSC8000 Video Spectral Comparator - Bairesac, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.bairesac.com/uploads/foster-freeman/vsc8000-ilovepdf-compressed.pdf

76. VSC8000 Video Spectral Comparator - Saint-Tech, accessed April 20, 2025, https://saint-tech.lv/pdf/bezopasnost/Daudzfunkcion%C4%81ls%20video%20spektr%C4%81lais%20komparators%20VSC8000.pdf

77. General Forensic Science MODULE No.28: Tools and Techniques, accessed April 20, 2025, https://epgp.inflibnet.ac.in/epgpdata/uploads/epgp_content/S000016FS/P001104/M019062/ET/1516186513FSC_P1_M28_e-text.pdf

78. VSC8000/HS | Foster + Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/vsc8000-hs/

79. Home | Foster + Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/

80. VSC®900 - Photon Lines Forensique, accessed April 20, 2025, https://photonlines-forensic.fr/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/VSC-900.pdf

81. VSC80 /FS | Foster + Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/vsc80-fs/

82. VSC®900 - Bairesac, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.bairesac.com/uploads/vsc-900.pdf

83. VSC9000 | Foster + Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/vsc-9000/

84. Document Examination - Saint-Tech, accessed April 20, 2025, http://saint-tech.lv/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/VSC-2024-Saint-Tech.pdf

85. Questioned Document Examination | Foster + Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/questioned-document-examination/

86. foster+freeman - Photon Lines Forensique, accessed April 20, 2025, https://photonlines-forensic.fr/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/FosterandFreeman_VSC80i.pdf

87. History of Innovation - Foster+Freeman, accessed April 20, 2025, https://fosterfreeman.com/innovation/

88. Final Report Forensic Document Examination & Ink Analysis 2023-FDEEE & 2023-CC2, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.ffint.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/2023-FDEEE-2023-CC2-Ink-Analysis-Final-Report-FFI.pdf

89. Hyperspectral imaging of gel pen inks: An emerging tool in document analysis | Request PDF - ResearchGate, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259158066_Hyperspectral_imaging_of_gel_pen_inks_An_emerging_tool_in_document_analysis

90. Forensic examination of ink by high-performance thin layer chromatography—The United States Secret Service Digital Ink Library | Request PDF - ResearchGate, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/49719055_Forensic_examination_of_ink_by_high-performance_thin_layer_chromatography-The_United_States_Secret_Service_Digital_Ink_Library

91. Questioned Documents Examination Test No. 23-5211 Summary Report, accessed April 20, 2025, https://cts-forensics.com/reports/23-5211_Web.pdf

92. Dual-Video Spectral Comparator Regula 4308, accessed April 20, 2025, https://regulaforensics.com/products/video-spectral-comparators/4308/

93. Video Spectral Comparator (VSC)-6000 | Download Scientific Diagram - ResearchGate, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/figure/deo-Spectral-Comparator-VSC-6000_fig1_367096222

94. Forensic Examination and Identification of Writing Inks on Documents - International Journal for Electronic Crime Investigation - Lahore Garrison University, accessed April 20, 2025, https://ijeci.lgu.edu.pk/ijeci/article/download/62/52/

95. Journal of Forensic Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://jfde.org/

96. Handwriting Analysis and Ink Chromatography - YouTube, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QRQBR0-UgYU

97. Document Examination | PPT - SlideShare, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.slideshare.net/slideshow/document-examination/1436000

98. Forensic Detection of Fraudulent Alteration in Ball-Point Pen Strokes ..., accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/220004663_Forensic_Detection_of_Fraudulent_Alteration_in_Ball-Point_Pen_Strokes

99. Dating inks on paper through chromatographic analysis of volatile ..., accessed April 20, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7888914/

100. Interpol questioned documents review 2019–2022 - PMC - PubMed Central, accessed April 20, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9974465/

101. Questioned Documents: Not Just Handwriting - The TASA Group, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.tasanet.com/Knowledge-Center/Archived-Webinars/ArtMID/475/ArticleID/84/Questioned-Documents-Not-Just-Handwriting

102. Yadav A, et al. Signature Distortion in Multi-generation Photocopy - Medwin Publishers, accessed April 20, 2025, https://medwinpublishers.com/IJFSC/signature-distortion-in-multi-generation-photocopy-a-review.pdf

103. exhibit b - U.S. Case Law, Court Opinions & Decisions :: Justia, accessed April 20, 2025, https://cases.justia.com/federal/district-courts/new-york/nywdce/1:2010cv00569/79861/326/0.pdf

104. (PDF) A comparative review of error rates in forensic handwriting examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/382656522_A_comparative_review_of_error_rates_in_forensic_handwriting_examination

105. Error mitigation in forensic handwriting examination - Oxford Academic, accessed April 20, 2025, https://academic.oup.com/fsr/article/9/4/owae065/7817821

106. Error mitigation in forensic handwriting examination - PubMed Central, accessed April 20, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11736425/

107. Handwriting Expert Witnesses: Role, Value, & Admissibility - Expert Institute, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.expertinstitute.com/resources/insights/handwriting-expert-witnesses-role-value-and-admissibility/

108. The validity and reliability of forensic handwriting examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.handwritinganalyst.co.za/post/2016/07/03/the-validity-and-reliability-of-forensic-handwriting-examination

109. Forensic Document Examination: FAQs, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.forensicsciencesimplified.org/docs/faqs.html

110. ISP Labs: Documents - IN.gov, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.in.gov/isp/labs/forensic-disciplines/documents/

111. Information for Attorneys: Collected and Requested Exemplars in Document Examination Cases, accessed April 20, 2025, https://www.jurispro.com/files/articles/Will%20-%20Exemplars.pdf

112. Collecting Exemplars | Attorney's Guide to Document Examination, accessed April 20, 2025, https://forensicdocumentexaminers.com/excerpt.html